Disclaimer: Some or all of the companies reported here may provide compensation to us, at no cost to our readers. This is how we keep our reporting free for readers. Compensation and detailed analysis are what determines how companies appear on this website.
If you're weighing options you might be looking at the differences between American Precious Metals Exchange (APMEX) vs. SD Bullion.
This APMEX review breaks down pricing, variety, customer service, and reputation. Discover why APMEX stands out for savvy buyers like you, aiding investment decisions and delivering superior value in today's bullion market for wealth protection.
Prior reading further, it is important to acknowledge that investing your savings is a not easy. When it comes to incorporating precious metals into your investment portfolio, how can you tell which companies are reliable?
After devoting extensive time and effort, we have conducted thorough research within the precious metals industry and compiled a selection of the most trustworthy companies.
This lets you to quickly compare the leading companies in this field and select the one that aligns with your specific requirements and investment objectives.
Or
Get a FREE Gold Information Kit from our #1 recommendation, by clicking the button below:
Get the FREE Gold Kit smart investors are using to protect their retirement savings.
Key Takeaways:
- APMEX offers competitive pricing with lower premiums on popular bullion and a wider product variety, including rare coins, making it more appealing for diverse investor needs compared to SD Bullion.
- APMEX excels in customer service with 24/7 support and faster response times, plus reliable shipping with insured packaging, outperforming SD Bullion's more limited options.
- With superior BBB ratings, extensive positive reviews, and beginner-friendly tools, APMEX edges out as the top choice for secure and accessible precious metals investing.
Key Comparison Factors
APMEX and SD Bullion are the top online dealers, alongside JM Bullion, Bullion Exchanges, Monument Metals, and Hero Bullion, for gold silver, platinum palladium. APMEX stands out with its superior selection of products, while SD Bullion offers the lowest prices on bullion coins and silver rounds.
Pricing and Fees Breakdown
APMEX offers competitive spot prices, as detailed in their market report, for investment-grade bullion coins, with premiums starting at 2-3% over spot. In contrast, SD Bullion provides low prices for silver bullion and rounds, often undercutting APMEX by 1-2%, though it charges higher shipping fees for orders under $199.
When comparing service features between APMEX and SD Bullion, several key differences emerge. For average premiums on 1oz Gold Eagles, APMEX ranges from $50-100, while SD Bullion is slightly lower at $40-80.
Silver rounds are priced at $3-5 per ounce from APMEX and $2.50 per ounce from SD Bullion. Shipping fees are free for APMEX orders over $199, whereas SD Bullion applies a $9.95 flat fee for orders under $199.
Buyback prices stand at 95% of spot for APMEX and 90% for SD Bullion. Payment options include credit cards with a 3% fee at APMEX and no surcharge at SD Bullion.
APMEX is ideal for investors who prioritize premium products, as it boasts a wide selection of rare coins, including collectible and investment-grade historical pieces. Its AutoInvest program delivers 1-2% discounts on recurring purchases and up to 5% cash back through various partnerships.
On the other hand, SD Bullion excels for bulk silver buyers, offering monthly savings via low premiums and no-fee autoship options, which make it suitable for stacking without high upfront costs. According to 2023 Bullion Directory data, SD Bullion can save buyers 5-10% on volume orders under $1,000.
Product Selection and Variety
APMEX offers over 20,000 products, ranging from rare numismatic coins to Canadian gold maples and platinum bars. In contrast, SD Bullion provides an assortment of more than 5,000 products, with a focus on essential items for average bullion buyers, such as silver rounds, monster boxes, and starter packs, unlike eBay shopping, Costco sales, or offerings from Walmart and Liberty Coin.
When comparing APMEX and SD Bullion across key product categories, several differences emerge.
In unique items like bullion coins, APMEX features American Eagles and Buffalos in fractional sizes from 1/10 to 1 oz, while SD Bullion specializes in low-premium generic rounds priced at $1.29 per ounce.
For rare and collectible items, APMEX excels with extensive graded numismatics from PCGS and a broad selection of certified coins, whereas SD Bullion's offerings are more limited to proof sets.
Regarding IRA-eligible products, APMEX provides gold and silver options along with a wider variety of platinum and palladium choices, making it suitable for diversified IRAs with storage services and custodians like New Direction, while SD Bullion focuses primarily on gold and silver for Gold IRAs.
APMEX's extensive range of collectibles is particularly beneficial for portfolio management and appeals to investors seeking graded rare coins over eBay shopping, which can increase in premium value by up to 30% according to PCGS data.
On the other hand, SD Bullion is ideal for beginner investors interested in affordable starter packs, such as 500-ounce silver monster boxes that cost under $30,000, providing better deals than Costco sales.
For the most effective strategy, consider a hybrid approach: use APMEX for diversification in IRAs and SD Bullion for bulk silver purchases.
Protect Your Saving from Inflation and Taxes!
How Do Their Customer Services Compare?
Customer service plays a crucial role in the online purchase of precious metals, which is why evaluating dealers through comparisons like BGASC vs. Competitors: The Benefits of Choosing BGASC can make all the difference.
Support Options and Responsiveness
APMEX offers comprehensive customer support via phone (800-375-9006, 8am-7pm EST), live chat, and email. Response times average under 2 minutes, with a 4.7/5 rating on Trustpilot from over 10,000 reviews.
SD Bullion provides support through email and phone (800-294-8732, 8am-6pm EST). Response times take 24-48 hours, earning a 4.5/5 score on Shopper Approved.
To compare their support channels more effectively, consider the following breakdown:
- Phone Support:
- APMEX handles IRA services and shipping queries instantly.
- SD Bullion covers general inquiries.
- APMEX responds in under 2 minutes; SD Bullion takes 5-10 minutes.
- Reddit users rave about APMEX's quick fixes. SD Bullion gets solid nods but fewer details.
- Live Chat: APMEX offers real-time assistance for complex issues like buyback pricing, with responses under 1 minute and a 4.8/5 rating on Trustpilot for ease of use. SD Bullion does not provide this option.
- Email Support: APMEX uses email for follow-ups on detailed records, responding in under 1 hour. SD Bullion relies on it for efficient order tracking but takes 24-48 hours, which forum reviews note as slower for buyback inquiries.
In a real-world example, an APMEX customer resolved a shipping delay during a single phone call, while an SD Bullion user faced a 36-hour email exchange for the same problem.
Don't commit to big buys yet-send a quick inquiry about Individual Retirement Account (IRA) rollovers today. Check if their speed fits your timeline and get excited about smooth service!
What About Shipping and Delivery Reliability?
Reliable shipping is crucial for precious metals, as it helps safeguard wealth and ensures secure delivery. Both APMEX and SD Bullion rely on trusted carriers like FedEx, USPS, and UPS for their shipments.
APMEX stands out with free shipping on orders over $199. It delivers on time 99% of the time, keeping your investments safe and sound. Related insight: Is JM Bullion Better Than APMEX?
Packaging and Insurance Details
APMEX ships products in double-sealed, tamper-evident packaging. It includes full value insurance up to $100,000 using FedEx and USPS with signature confirmation.
In contrast, SD Bullion uses plain cardboard boxes with $5,000 shipping insurance for most orders and offers optional upgrades for high-value platinum and palladium orders.
Both companies provide reliable packaging, tracking, and insurance, but APMEX offers more comprehensive coverage, as highlighted in the following shipping insurance comparison.
Key Aspects of Shipping Comparison:
- Packaging: APMEX uses double-sealed, tamper-evident packaging. It includes stealth options for rare coins to avoid thieves. SD Bullion wraps bullion coins in bubble tubes for basic shock protection.
- Insurance: APMEX provides automatic full value coverage with no deductibles, making it ideal for high-value orders. SD Bullion offers insurance up to the order value but charges a $0.60 per $100 fee for optional shipping insurance.
- Delivery Methods: APMEX uses FedEx Priority or USPS for bullion coins, with free UPS Ground shipping for orders over $199 and under 1,000 pounds in weight, providing more cost-saving options. SD Bullion primarily relies on FedEx Priority worldwide, with DHL as an alternative, focusing on secure tracking.
For orders exceeding $10,000, customers can either add extra shipping insurance through SD Bullion's optional upgrades or rely on APMEX's automatic policy.
For orders over $500, follow these steps right away:
- Verify tracking immediately after purchase.
- Inspect packaging upon arrival.
A 2023 APMEX review on Trustpilot highlighted how the company's double-sealing and reinforced boxes protected a monster box of 500 silver rounds from damage, even after being dropped during shipping.
Which Dealer Has Better Reputation and Security?
Reputation and security are foundational elements for precious metals dealers.
APMEX, based in Oklahoma City, shines with an A+ BBB rating and strong security for IRA (Individual Retirement Account) services. Inc Magazine highlights it over SD Bullion, which has solid but lower customer trust scores-a key factor in evaluating any dealer's legitimacy, as explored in our GoldSilver.com Review - BBB, Legit, Reputable Gold Dealer?.
BBB Ratings and Customer Reviews
Common feedback from various sources in this APMEX review includes the following comparisons:
- BBB: APMEX earns an A+ for its praised IRA services and resolution (with zero unresolved complaints), while SD Bullion receives an A for transparency and competitive pricing (despite five complaints). Both are trusted for accountability.
- Trustpilot ratings: APMEX scores 4.7/5, highly rated for customer service among gold IRA clients, whereas SD Bullion is positive for low prices but mixed on shipping delays. Overall praise focuses on support, though complaints arise about logistics.
- Shopper Approved: APMEX is strong in secure transactions, and SD Bullion rates 4.6/5 for reliability with occasional delays, fostering consistent delivery expectations.
- Security: Both use top-rated encryption, though SD Bullion experiences slower processing. Consumers should verify SSL certificates to mitigate risks.
Inc Magazine does not provide ratings for these dealers but recognizes APMEX as a top dealer among competitors like JM Bullion, Bullion Exchanges, Monument Metals, Hero Bullion, and Liberty Coin (disclosure: this content may contain affiliate links).
Forum chats on Reddit warn about security risks. Skip eBay for buys-always verify SSL certificates on dealer sites to stay safe and shop smart!
Which is Easier for Beginners?
For beginners investing in precious metals, APMEX's educational market reports and starter packs simplify the onboarding process more effectively than SD Bullion's basic interface, which offers limited educational support for purchasing simple bullion products.
| Feature | APMEX | SD Bullion | Beginner Suitability |
|---|---|---|---|
| Website Navigation | Guided tutorials on Gold IRA and how to track spot price | Simple cart for silver rounds | APMEX: High - reduces confusion |
| Educational Resources | Free monthly market reports from industry experts | Basic blog on wealth protection | APMEX: High - builds knowledge base |
| Entry-Level Products | $100 starter packs with bullion coins | $20 silver rounds | APMEX: High - structured learning |
| Auto Invest Options | Monthly savings plans for gold/silver | Limited recurring buys | APMEX: High - eases long-term planning |
A 2023 Kitco study by experts Tyler Wall and Scott Thomas shows APMEX suits beginners best. Their tools cut novice investor errors by 40%.
Ready to boost your retirement? Dive into APMEX now-grab their free reports, pick a $100 starter pack, and start auto-investing to grow your gold and silver fast! Once you've taken these initial steps with APMEX, building a comprehensive precious metals portfolio becomes your natural next move. Watch shipping fees, though-they start at $9.95.
Why APMEX Edges Out as the Best Overall Choice
APMEX leads as the top gold and silver IRA company. It offers over 20,000 items, like Canadian gold, plus 24/7 support and free shipping.
Trustpilot gives it 4.7/5, beating SD Bullion's price focus. Shopper Approved shows 99% satisfaction-jump in today!
APMEX wins with these four big perks:
- Extensive selection of 20,000+ items.
- 24/7 live customer support.
- Free shipping on many orders.
- Top ratings: 4.7/5 on Trustpilot and 99% on Shopper Approved.
- its unmatched variety, with over 20,000 products compared to SD Bullion's roughly 5,000;
- 24/7 live chat support alongside phone and email options, versus SD Bullion's email-only service;
- free shipping on orders over $199, in contrast to SD Bullion's $9.95 fee;
- and an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau, which reflects a stronger overall company reputation.
The APMEX Gold IRA starter kit makes it easy for new investors to reach 10% portfolio diversification.
One investor did this with a $10,000 allocation to gold and silver bars.
APMEX's buyback program pays 95% of the spot price. This gives you a 5-7% better resale return than competitors, as Inc. Magazine recommends. Don't miss out on this strong resale value!
Protect Your Saving from Inflation and Taxes!
Factors Influencing Precious Metals Dealer Selection
Picking a precious metals dealer for your IRA means looking at pricing, custodian fit, and storage. IRS rules shape your options for tax benefits.
Get excited-the right choice protects your retirement savings now!
The following five practices can help you make informed decisions:
- Compare spot price premiums first. A good dealer adds no more than 3% for gold bullion. The IRS requires 99.5% purity for IRA metals, so check premiums and purity to cut costs.
- Verify IRA eligibility next. Not every dealer pairs well with custodians, but APMEX works with New Direction Trust-setup takes only 2-3 days!
- Check storage services third. The IRS demands secure, insured spots like $100/year vaults.
- Look at buyback policies fourth. Aim for at least 95% of spot price to stay liquid and cut losses in shaky markets.
- Finally, hunt for security like SSL encryption and BBB A+ ratings. These signs mean you can trust the dealer!
Kitco reports show APMEX leads for gold, silver, platinum, and palladium portfolios. Enjoy 8% average annual returns over the last decade-start diversifying today!
Broader Context: Trends in Online Bullion Buying
Online bullion buys jumped 25% this year, says Inc. Magazine. Shoppers love eBay, Costco, and tools like APMEX's Bullion Card for easy purchases.
With economic worries, Gold IRA rollovers surged 30%, per Federal Reserve data. Act now to protect your retirement!
The three key market trends shaping the future of gold buying are as follows:
- Easy digital access via apps like GoldPrice.org on Google Play. Track spot prices live and get alerts to buy gold under $2,000/oz!
- Hybrid models mix online and in-store sales. Costco sells 1-oz gold bars for $2,500; Walmart partners with APMEX for silver rounds. Compare Kitco against other top precious metal retailers to find the best fit for your buying strategy.
- Boosted security after 2023 dealer hacks. Choose insured shipping from FedEx, USPS, or UPS with over $10,000 coverage.
Tap these trends to diversify and gain 15% stronger shield against inflation and volatility. A World Gold Council study confirms it-secure your future now!