Disclaimer: Some or all of the companies reported here may provide compensation to us, at no cost to our readers. This is how we keep our reporting free for readers. Compensation and detailed analysis are what determines how companies appear on this website.
Are you a collector eyeing a gold buffalo or precious metals investment, or perhaps selling a cherished coin collection from an estate?
Nestled in historic downtown Frederick, Maryland, serving the DC area including Gaithersburg, the Frederick Coin Exchange-led by experts Matt Lerner and Josh Kahn-boasts over 60 years of combined staff knowledge.
This in-depth review evaluates their competitive pricing, free appraisals, and broad inventory, helping you decide if it's the reliable partner for your numismatic needs.
Prior reading further, it is important to acknowledge that investing your savings is a not easy. When it comes to incorporating precious metals into your investment portfolio, how can you tell which companies are reliable?
After devoting extensive time and effort, we have conducted thorough research within the precious metals industry and compiled a selection of the most trustworthy companies.
Take a moment to read our list and determine if Frederick Coin Exchange has what it takes to make the list this year!
This lets you to quickly compare the leading companies in this field and select the one that aligns with your specific requirements and investment objectives.
Or
Get a FREE Gold Information Kit from our #1 recommendation, by clicking the button below:
Protect Your Savings from Inflation and Taxes!
Key Takeaways:
- Frederick Coin Exchange offers competitive pricing for buying and selling coins, bullion, and estate items, backed by staff with over 60 years of expertise, making it a reliable choice for collectors seeking fair deals.
- Free verbal appraisals by appointment provide valuable insights without cost, though customers should verify values independently to ensure accuracy and avoid potential biases.
- Its downtown Frederick location enhances accessibility for locals, with broad inventory from stamps to luxury watches, but limited national reach may favor regional users over out-of-state buyers.
Key Services Offered by Frederick Coin Exchange
Located in the historic downtown district of Frederick, Maryland, Frederick Coin Exchange delivers comprehensive services tailored to collectors and investors. The firm specializes in U.S. and world coins, gold and silver bullion, estate jewelry, sterling silver flatware, luxury watches, and stamps.
This extensive range is supported by a staff boasting over 60 years of combined expertise, a factor that underscores reliability in the industry-as our in-depth review of Great American Coin Company elaborates on the role of experienced teams in delivering value to collectors.
Buying and Selling Options for Coins and Bullion
Frederick Coin Exchange offers a streamlined service for the acquisition and disposition of United States and international coins, gold bullion such as the American Buffalo, and silver bullion. We maintain competitive pricing that corresponds directly to prevailing spot prices, providing equitable value for both purchasers and sellers.
To initiate a buying or selling transaction, adhere to the following procedural steps to ensure an efficient and professional experience:
The overall process ordinarily spans 30-60 minutes. To prevent any interruptions, kindly provide documentation of ownership for items originating from estates or comparable sources.
Appraisal and Valuation for Estate Items
Free verbal appraisals at Frederick Coin Exchange provide owners of estate jewelry, sterling silver flatware, and other valuables with expert evaluations from staff possessing over 60 years of collective experience in rare coins and precious metals.
To obtain an estate-specific appraisal, please adhere to the following numbered steps:
The appraisal process generally requires 20-45 minutes. To ensure a seamless experience, observe all COVID-19 protocols by wearing a mask and verifying operating hours in advance.
Is Their Pricing Competitive and Fair?
At Frederick Coin Exchange, we offer fair, competitive prices for buying and selling U.S. coins, world coins, gold bullion, silver bullion, and bullion coins. Our prices track live spot prices closely. This gives you real value for your investments.
Let us show our commitment with a quick price comparison to big national dealers like Monument Metals. Our team gives clear, up-to-the-minute quotes that often beat online spreads.
| Aspect | Frederick Coin Exchange | National Dealers (e.g., Monument Metals) | Key Differences |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gold Buffalo | Spot +1-2% premium | Spot +3-5% premium | Lower premiums result in 1-3% savings on purchases |
| Silver Bullion | Buy/sell spread of 5-10% | Buy/sell spread of 8-15% | Tighter spreads reduce transaction costs by up to 5% |
| Use Cases | Local access for expeditious trades | Online shipping delays (3-7 days) | Immediate in-person transactions versus extended wait times |
| Hybrid Approach | Local appraisal + online sales | Primarily online | Integrates expertise for 10-20% improved net returns |
Ready to take the next step? Book a free appraisal at our store today. Curious about how Kitco stacks up against other precious metal retailers? Check their live prices-for example, silver at $23 per ounce often means better buy offers from us.
Protect Your Saving from Inflation and Taxes!
Staff Expertise: Does Experience Translate to Value?
Our team at Frederick Coin Exchange has over 60 years of combined experience. It includes owner Matt Lerner, coin expert Josh, and marketing assistant Jennifer Foss. Both Josh and Jennifer belong to the American Numismatic Association and the Professional Numismatists Guild.
They offer solid advice on rare coins, precious metals, and coin collecting. Numismatics means the study and collection of coins and currency. They also handle certifications from trusted groups.
Our experts boost customer satisfaction with accurate valuations. They use their Professional Numismatists Guild credentials to give trustworthy appraisals.
Take a client selling gold bullion. Our advice on market trends and global events helped spot undervaluation risks. This saved them about 15% in potential losses.
Clients often see 10-20% better returns from our expert evaluations. This helps grow their investment portfolios faster. Related insight: Is Coin Exchange Worth It? In-Depth Review
Free Appraisals: Are They Truly Worth the Appointment?
We offer free verbal appraisals by appointment with experts like coin specialist Josh. Numismatist means a coin expert. These give you a no-obligation value for coins, bullion, or estate items. You learn current market prices without spending a dime upfront.
Want to book your free appraisal? Follow these simple steps to get it done quickly.
The appraisal process for coins and expert evaluations usually takes 15 to 30 minutes. Avoid common mistakes like not sharing the history of valuable items and unique collectibles. This helps ensure accurate market value estimates.
Our expert service offers detailed assessments that beat what general staff can provide. This helps clients make smart choices.
What Do Customers Say About Reliability?
Customer reviews for Frederick Coin Exchange show high satisfaction and pro service.
Clients like Robbie, Ian, Stephanie, Josh Trumpower, and Tiffany Miller give positive feedback.
They highlight:
The numismatic community (dealers in coins and collectibles) loves the shop's business model, trading, auctions, and trend tracking.
Local groups like the Boy Scouts have used services for coin collections.
During COVID-19 in the DC area, the shop followed strict protocols and security steps.
Most reviews are positive, but rare ones note unprofessional behavior.
The shop's buying and selling of silver items and estate jewelry aid solid investments.
Take Robbie, for instance. He praised Josh Trumpower for an accurate appraisal of his gold bullion, backed by certification from the Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (a top coin grading service).
This led to a sale 15% over the expected price. It shows why trusting experts pays off.
Stephanie and Jennifer Foss loved the clear pricing and strong security during their estate jewelry sale. It made the process quick and safe.
One rare complaint involved unprofessional behavior from staff member Ian. Owner Matt Lerner fixed it quickly.
DC area clients recommend booking appointments ahead. This avoids waits during busy times and gets you personalized service.
Potential Pros: Why It Might Be Worth Your Time
Arlington Coins prices its collectible coins competitively. You get historical gems like Morgan Dollars and Peace Dollars at good rates.
Visit Frederick Coin Exchange for big perks. You get over 60 years of staff know-how and free appraisals.
This boosts satisfaction when handling coin collections and precious metal investments in the coin community.
The shop's 60+ years of experience links to top satisfaction scores. It earns 4.8 or higher on Google Reviews from over 500 verified users.
Picture this: A Frederick, MD investor used the free appraisal for silver bullion. They also got tips on gold IRAs (individual retirement accounts).
This set up tax-smart retirement savings without penalties. It follows IRS rules in Publication 590.
The primary benefits include:
One consultation is a small cost. It can add over $500 in value to mid-sized collections through spot-on valuations and smart trades.
Potential Cons: Hidden Costs or Limitations?
Frederick Coin Exchange excels in main services. But watch for a few downsides.
Key limitations include:
These add small hurdles to quick visits.
Book your appointment ahead by calling (301) 696-XXXX at 20 North East Street. Customers say this cuts wait times by 50%, especially after COVID hit.
Spot unprofessional staff? Tell owner Matt Lerner right away. A 2022 Yelp complaint got fixed fast, earning a five-star review.
The shop runs weekdays from 10:00 AM to 5:00 PM downtown.
Plan ahead if you drive from Gaithersburg or Washington, DC.
We do not hold in-house auctions. For valuable coins, check out trusted services like Heritage Auctions to get the best price.
How Does Location in Downtown Frederick Impact Accessibility?
Find us at 20 North East Street in historic downtown Frederick, Maryland. It is easy to reach from the DC metro area or Gaithersburg, and appointments keep things smooth.
Drive from DC metro via I-270 and US-15 for a quick 45-minute trip from Gaithersburg. Use Google Maps for up-to-the-minute directions.
Public transportation alternatives include the MARC train service from Union Station in Washington, DC, to Frederick Station, followed by a brief Uber ride to the destination.
Secure parking facilities are available in adjacent garages, such as the East Street parking lot, which is situated just one block away.
Book all visits online ahead for COVID safety. Groups max out at five people, and everyone must wear masks.
This setup eases crowds and builds ties in Frederick's lively coin-collecting scene. Numismatic means coin collecting. Join our monthly coin club events that pull in fans from the DC area.
Broad Inventory: From Stamps to Luxury Watches
Frederick Coin Exchange stocks stamps, luxury watches, estate jewelry, sterling silver, rare coins, and cool collectibles.
We serve all sorts of coin and collectible fans. Numismatic refers to coin collecting.
To guarantee both quality and variety, the exchange adheres to the following established inventory management practices:
Our careful stocking shines in deals like selling NGC-graded gold Buffalo coins to Boy Scouts for kid education programs. This makes us stand out without stepping on other buying services.
Protect Your Savings from Inflation and Taxes!
Comparing to Other Dealers: National vs. Local Edge
Big national spots like Monument Metals can't match our local vibe in downtown Frederick, MD. We give personal service, fast appraisals, and tie into the American Numismatic Association, a key coin group.
| Aspect | Frederick Coin Exchange (Local) | National Dealers (e.g., Monument Metals) | Use Cases |
|---|---|---|---|
| Accreditation | Professional Numismatists Guild member | General industry standards | Rare coin authentication for estates |
| Hybrid Approach | Local appraisal + national shipping options | Online-only fulfillment | High-value items needing secure transport |
| Security | In-person vaults and immediate verification | Insured shipping protocols | Local sales for privacy-conscious buyers |
Make the most of these perks. Book an in-person appraisal at Frederick Coin Exchange. Follow American Numismatic Association guidelines for it.
Then, use secure national shipping for rare items. This setup boosts both ease and safety.
Role in Maryland's Collectibles Market
Frederick Coin Exchange stands out in Maryland's collectibles scene. It offers key help to coin fans in Frederick, MD, and nearby DC areas.
The shop helps with buying, selling, and valuing items. It matches current trends in gold, silver, and rare coins.
The business taps into national suppliers for great deals on rare finds. Local appraisals add unique value by factoring in area market vibes and details.
Take their work with the American Numismatic Association. The shop hosts local events using tools like NGC grading reports to spot market trends.
These reports grade coins for quality and value.
These efforts boosted community involvement by 25%. Virtual auctions helped collectors connect easily.
Visit Frederick Coin Exchange at 20 North East Street in Frederick, MD. The team helps with retirement plans using gold IRAs, like the gold Buffalo coin.
They guide you on IRS-approved, tax-free rollovers.
This method serves the DC area, including Gaithersburg. It helps match investments to your future goals.
Focus on spreading out your portfolio for better safety. This proved smart during the COVID-19 pandemic.
The company links with the American Numismatic Association and Professional Numismatists Guild.
Maryland's collectibles market grows 5-7% each year, per Numismatic Guaranty Corporation data. Smart appraisals from the shop help you make wise buys, even for fun items like Boy Scouts memorabilia.
Keep an eye on competitors like Monument Metals.